You Don't Need Etsy: An Online Store for Makers
August 16, 2026 · 5 min read
Why does it feel like Etsy is taking more every year?
You list a painting for $80. Someone buys it. By the time the listing fee, the 6.5% transaction fee, and the payment processing fee are all taken out, you've lost close to a tenth of the sale before shipping even enters the picture. List it again after it sells, and you pay the listing fee again. Run any kind of promoted listing or offsite ad, and the cut climbs further.
None of this is a scandal. Etsy built a marketplace and marketplaces charge rent. But it means the fee isn't really for selling online. It's for being found inside somebody else's search results, next to nine other people who paint similar things. You are not just paying to take payment. You're paying for shelf space you don't control.
If what you actually want is a place to show your work and let people buy it, you don't need a marketplace. You need a storefront.
What's the actual difference between a marketplace and a storefront?
A marketplace puts you next to your competitors and takes a percentage for the traffic. A storefront is just yours: your name, your photos, your prices, one link. Nobody is buying your candle instead of the seven other candles ranked above it, because there's no ranking. There's just your shop.
That's what an order page on Yaha is. You set it up at yaha.app/join, add your pieces with photos and prices, and you get a real link, yaha.app/r/your-name, that works anywhere: your Instagram bio, a QR code at a craft fair, a text to a customer who asked if you still have the blue one. There's no monthly fee, and no listing fee that renews every time something sells. Yaha takes a small cut only when an order actually goes through.
Some real examples already live on it. Lorna Waweru Art sells original paintings direct from her own page. Gora Scents sells handmade candles and fragrance the same way, one link, no marketplace competing for attention above it. The Amber Design Studio runs custom design work through their page instead of a portfolio site that can't take payment at all.
Does this only work for visual art?
No. The pattern is the same for anyone making a physical thing by hand and selling it directly to a person who already wants it.
Jewelry and small-batch craft. If you're hand-stringing beads or forging metal, every sale on a marketplace is competing against mass factory listings using the same keywords. On your own page, a customer who found you through a friend's tag or a market stall goes straight to your pieces, nothing else.
Clothing drops. Launching a small collection, ten pieces, one size run, done? A storefront handles this better than a marketplace built for permanent catalogs. Put the collection up, share the link the morning it drops, and take orders while it's still fresh. When it sells out, take it down.
Home bakers and cake makers. A cake isn't a listing that sits for four months. It's made to order, this week, for someone's Saturday. Dreamy Donuts in Nairobi runs exactly this: a rotating menu, ordered ahead, ready when the customer arrives. We wrote more about this setup in How to Set Up Online Pickup Ordering for Your Restaurant, and the same logic applies whether you're selling loaves or lasagna.
Florists. Bouquets are seasonal, time-sensitive, and often ordered for someone else entirely, a birthday, an apology, a funeral. That's a different kind of order page than a shelf of earrings, and we've written specifically about that scenario in Send Flowers, Food or a Gift to Someone Else.
Fashion and accessories. Nissi Fashion Trends and FioDany Styles, both in Nairobi, sell clothing and accessories through their own pages rather than fighting for placement inside a marketplace search.
What about people who don't make physical objects at all?
The same storefront works for services and specialty goods too. Twinkle Beauty Shop sells beauty products this way. Zain Gas & Accessories in Kitengela sells household goods. Lake Victoria Aquaculture sells fish, which is about as far from Etsy's original craft-fair premise as it gets, and that's the point: the underlying idea isn't "a place for handmade things." It's a place for anyone with something to sell and no reason to pay rent to a platform that ranks them against strangers.
What do you actually lose by leaving a marketplace?
Mostly, you lose nothing you were using. You don't lose search traffic you were never really getting, since most Etsy sellers report that the majority of their sales come from people who already know them, not cold marketplace discovery. You don't lose the fee protection, because there wasn't any, marketplaces charge whether the sale was profitable for you or not. What you gain is a link that's entirely yours, a customer relationship that isn't mediated by someone else's algorithm, and a cut that's small and only ever comes out of money you actually made.
If you're already selling through Instagram, the same order page slots into your bio without you needing a separate website. We covered that setup in Sell on Instagram Without Building a Website.
How do you actually start?
Go to yaha.app/join, add what you make, and share the link. It takes minutes, not a weekend, and there's nothing to cancel later because there was never a subscription to begin with.
You made the thing. You shouldn't have to pay rent to sell it.